‘Shrek The Musical’ at the John W. Engeman Theater is pure fairytale gold
The John W. Engeman Theater in Northport has once again delivered a spectacular production, this time bringing the beloved green ogre and his fairytale friends to life with their vibrant and heartfelt staging of Shrek the Musical. Running through August 23r, this is an absolute must-see for audiences of all ages.
Based on the wildly popular animated film and William Steig’s original book, Shrek the Musical first enchanted Broadway audiences in 2008. With a catchy score by Jeanine Tesori and clever book and lyrics by David Lindsay-Abaire, the musical takes us on a journey that’s both hilarious and deeply touching.
Directed by Danielle Aliotta, it tells the story of Shrek, a hulking green ogre who, after being mocked and feared his entire life, retreats to an ugly green swamp for isolation. His peace is shattered, however, when a host of banished fairytale creatures, some including the Gingerbread Man, the Three Little Pigs, Pinocchio, and the Big Bad Wolf, are sent to his swamp by the diminutive, tyrannical Lord Farquaad.
To reclaim his solitude, Shrek strikes a deal with Farquaad to rescue Princess Fiona from a dragon-guarded tower, and the fairytale creatures can return to their homes. Joined by the fast-talking, eternally optimistic Donkey, Shrek embarks on a quest that will challenge his perceptions of himself and others and reveal a princess who isn’t quite what he (or anyone else) expects.
From the moment the curtain rises on Dennis Kaydanov’s whimsical scenic design, transporting us straight into the fairytale land, you know you’re in for a treat. Also choreographed by Aliotta, the production is a whirlwind of energetic dance numbers, genuinely hilarious comedic timing, and moments of surprising tenderness.
The ensemble opens with the delightful “Story of My Life,” immediately establishing the quirky world of banished creatures, and Shrek’s journey begins with the poignant “Big Bright Beautiful World.”
Austin Sidito delivers a truly captivating performance as Shrek, finding the perfect balance between the ogre’s gruff exterior and his deeply tender, misunderstood heart. His powerful voice fills the theater, making us root for him from his first grumble to his final triumphant roar. Honestly, he sounds just like Mike Myers, who played the original Shrek in the movie.
Alongside him, Jessica Mae Murphy shines as Princess Fiona, bringing a radiant energy and impressive vocal range to the role. Her rendition of “I Know It’s Today,” sung by her character at different ages, beautifully conveys Fiona’s long-held dreams, and her comedic timing is spot-on, particularly in her “Morning Person” antics. Her playful, competitive duet “I Think I Got You Beat” with Shrek is a standout, full of surprising charm.
But what’s Shrek without his trusty (and chatty) sidekick? Jack O’Connor is an absolute revelation as Donkey, stealing every scene with his boundless energy, quick wit and irresistible charm. His performance is a masterclass in comedic timing, leaving the audience laughing with almost every line and dance move.
Will Logan’s portrayal of the vertically challenged, hilariously narcissistic Lord Farquaad is simply brilliant. Logan commits entirely to the physical comedy and exaggerated villainy, earning huge laughs and a few gasps of admiration for his unique approach to the role — he even walks on his knees to cater to the short character.
The magic extends far beyond the principal characters. The entire ensemble, under Andrew McCluskey’s music direction, is a powerhouse of talent. Each fairytale creature, from Joslyn Shepard-Stivers’ sassy Gingy (a puppet with gum drop buttons!) to Max Unlu’s endearing Pinocchio, brings their character to life with vibrant personality and impressive vocals.
Their rousing anthem, “Freak Flag,” is a powerful moment of self-acceptance and defiance that resonates deeply. Laura McGauley’s spectacular costume design explodes with color and creativity, perfectly embodying each character’s unique charm, while Joey Tito’s lighting design adds a magical glow to every scene.
Shrek the Musical at the Engeman Theater is more than just a children’s story — it’s a celebration of individuality, friendship, and finding love in unexpected places. It’s packed with dance-worthy songs, dazzling choreography and enough heart and humor to keep every member of the family entertained from start to finish. As for the grand finale? A joyous finale with the classic hit “I’m a Believer” that had the entire theater up from their seats moving and grooving.
Do not miss your chance to embark on this fantastic adventure. Stop by the lobby on your way out for autographs and photos with the main cast.
